!["[Updated] Stop Frames Dropping OBS Troubleshooting Guide for 2024"](https://www.lifewire.com/thmb/s_49EdazIwlAKelLWFU8LSaOlMk=/400x300/filters:no_upscale():max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/GettyImages-585151372-a659baf0c7b441b9b7e7896716b12784.jpg)
"[Updated] Stop Frames Dropping OBS Troubleshooting Guide for 2024"
![](/images/site-logo.png)
Stop Frames Dropping: OBS Troubleshooting Guide
Nothing could be more annoying while recording or streaming than finding out that the frames are getting dropped by the recording or streaming software you are using. Frame drop is a common issue if you are using OBS Studio for recording high-end games or live streaming with high output resolution. You can easily understand about OBS drop frames while streaming when your viewers complain about lagging and stuttering.
In fact, you can even check OBS stream status to find out about OBS Studio drop frames. Dropping frames literally ruins the recording and hence, it needs to be fixed before further operation. You need to understand the reasons behind OBS losing frames and take actions accordingly to fix the issue. In this article, we will explain the reasons and provide all the possible solutions to prevent OBS dropping frames recording and streaming.
Part 1. Why OBS Drops Frames?
OBS can drop the frame rate due to various reasons. When too many frames are dropped, the streaming server is disconnected. Dropped frames are one of the main causes which can affect streaming playback. Besides, a drop in frames leads to bad recording of screen and gameplay. Here are some of the reasons why OBS drops frames while recording or streaming.
- Your computer has an unstable internet connection.
- Your computer has low-end hardware configuration.
- Your video output resolution is very high.
- Your video bitrate is very high.
- Your internet upload speed is rather low.
- antivirus or firewall is messing with OBS Studio.
Part 2. How To Fix OBS Dropping Frame?
Way 1. Update OBS & Run as an Administrator
It is important to know that you are using the latest version of OBS. This helps to prevent encoding overload as well as problems due to stuttering. Make sure that you run OBS as an administrator. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Download and install the latest version of OBS Studio.
Step 2: Go to Start menu and search for OBS Studio.
Step 3: Right-click on the OBS icon and select Run As Administrator option.
Way 2. Reduce The Output Resolution
When you reduce the resolution, the video quality gets lowered. But for smooth streaming and recording, you have no other option. When you reduce resolution, you require less CPU usage and less internet bandwidth. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Open OBS and go to Settings.
Step 2: Select Video tab. You will see Base and Output resolution.
Step 3: You have to reduce Output Resolution from the current or default setting.
Step 4: Click Apply for saving the changes followed by Ok button.
Way 3. Reduce The Video Bitrate
OBS generally does not maintain a specified bitrate. It keeps on changing the bitrate as per the available condition like CPU usage level and bandwidth and speed of internet connection. When there are constant changes in the bitrate, there is a likelihood of stuttering effect. Even though it has come up with Dynamic bitrate which will automatically reduce the bitrate, but it increases the bitrate when there is no congestion. You can reduce the bitrate by going through these steps.
Step 1: Open OBS Studio and click on Settings button.
Step 2: Go to Output tab and look for Video Bitrate option.
Step 3: Lower the video bitrate from the default or current value.
Step 4: Click on Apply and OK button.
Way 4. Change OBS Process Priority
By changing the OBS process priority from Normal to Above Normal, there could be more processing power availability for OBS Studio. It helps in solving the problem of frame drop by driving performance from the system for better encoding and rendering. Here are the steps for changing OBS process priority.
Step 1: Launch OBS and go to Settings.
Step 3: Go to Advanced tab and look for Process Priority.
Step 4: You will have to change it to ‘Above Normal’ from ‘Normal’.
Step 5: Click Apply followed by Ok button.
Way 5. Update Network Driver
Dropped frame rates can happen due to the outdated network adapter driver. For this, it is important to look for the latest version of the driver. With up-to-date drivers, there will be a smooth connection when you are streaming or playing online games. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: From Start menu, search for Device Manager and open it.
Step 2: Find Network Adapters and click on it to expand.
Step 3: Find your LAN card and right-click on it.
Step 4: From the menu, select Update Driver option.
Follow the onscreen instruction to complete the process and restart your computer.
Way 6. Turn Off Your Firewall and Antivirus
There can be instances where firewalls can block the port for RTMP. It can interfere with the internet connection leading to dropping frames. Similarly, antivirus software messes with any third-party software and prevents regular operations. You have to temporarily turn off real-time protection as well as the antivirus software. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Go to Start menu and search for Firewall.
Step 2: Open Firewall & Network Protection.
Step 3: Turn off firewall for domain, private and public network temporarily to fix dropping frame issue.
Step 4: Go to Virus & Threat Protection.
Step 5: Under Virus & Threat Protection section. Click on Manage Settings.
Step 6: Turn on real-time Protection option as well as other available options as applicable.
Way 7. Use OBS Alternative Tool
If the problem is not solved even after trying out all the above-mentioned ways to fix OBS dropping frames recording, you need to switch to a better alternative for recording high-quality videos without drop frame issue. We recommend Wondershare Filmora which is a professional video recorder and video editor application. You can record your screen and webcam at any resolution and record audio from different sources as well. Most importantly, it uses the system resources optimally to avoid frame dropping issues. Here are the steps to record screen with Filmora.
For Win 7 or later (64-bit)
For macOS 10.12 or later
Step 1: Download and install Wondershare Filmora. Launch Filmora and click on PC Screen option for screen recording.
Step 2: Choose recording screen dimensions and audio sources. You can enable Record Camera Stream option to capture your video through picture-in-picture mode.
Step 3: Click on Record button to start recording. Use F9 hotkey to stop recording. You can your recording instantly and click on Export button to save on your hard drive.
Conclusion
OBS drop frame is probably the most common issue reported by OBS users. Whenever you try to record high-quality videos such as at 4K resolution or you are streaming at high-quality resolution, OBS losing frames is inevitable unless you have a high-end computer. You should try out all the possible ways to avoid the issue. Otherwise, you can switch to Filmora to record high-quality videos without any frame drop issue.
Part 2. How To Fix OBS Dropping Frame?
Way 1. Update OBS & Run as an Administrator
It is important to know that you are using the latest version of OBS. This helps to prevent encoding overload as well as problems due to stuttering. Make sure that you run OBS as an administrator. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Download and install the latest version of OBS Studio.
Step 2: Go to Start menu and search for OBS Studio.
Step 3: Right-click on the OBS icon and select Run As Administrator option.
Way 2. Reduce The Output Resolution
When you reduce the resolution, the video quality gets lowered. But for smooth streaming and recording, you have no other option. When you reduce resolution, you require less CPU usage and less internet bandwidth. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Open OBS and go to Settings.
Step 2: Select Video tab. You will see Base and Output resolution.
Step 3: You have to reduce Output Resolution from the current or default setting.
Step 4: Click Apply for saving the changes followed by Ok button.
Way 3. Reduce The Video Bitrate
OBS generally does not maintain a specified bitrate. It keeps on changing the bitrate as per the available condition like CPU usage level and bandwidth and speed of internet connection. When there are constant changes in the bitrate, there is a likelihood of stuttering effect. Even though it has come up with Dynamic bitrate which will automatically reduce the bitrate, but it increases the bitrate when there is no congestion. You can reduce the bitrate by going through these steps.
Step 1: Open OBS Studio and click on Settings button.
Step 2: Go to Output tab and look for Video Bitrate option.
Step 3: Lower the video bitrate from the default or current value.
Step 4: Click on Apply and OK button.
Way 4. Change OBS Process Priority
By changing the OBS process priority from Normal to Above Normal, there could be more processing power availability for OBS Studio. It helps in solving the problem of frame drop by driving performance from the system for better encoding and rendering. Here are the steps for changing OBS process priority.
Step 1: Launch OBS and go to Settings.
Step 3: Go to Advanced tab and look for Process Priority.
Step 4: You will have to change it to ‘Above Normal’ from ‘Normal’.
Step 5: Click Apply followed by Ok button.
Way 5. Update Network Driver
Dropped frame rates can happen due to the outdated network adapter driver. For this, it is important to look for the latest version of the driver. With up-to-date drivers, there will be a smooth connection when you are streaming or playing online games. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: From Start menu, search for Device Manager and open it.
Step 2: Find Network Adapters and click on it to expand.
Step 3: Find your LAN card and right-click on it.
Step 4: From the menu, select Update Driver option.
Follow the onscreen instruction to complete the process and restart your computer.
Way 6. Turn Off Your Firewall and Antivirus
There can be instances where firewalls can block the port for RTMP. It can interfere with the internet connection leading to dropping frames. Similarly, antivirus software messes with any third-party software and prevents regular operations. You have to temporarily turn off real-time protection as well as the antivirus software. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Go to Start menu and search for Firewall.
Step 2: Open Firewall & Network Protection.
Step 3: Turn off firewall for domain, private and public network temporarily to fix dropping frame issue.
Step 4: Go to Virus & Threat Protection.
Step 5: Under Virus & Threat Protection section. Click on Manage Settings.
Step 6: Turn on real-time Protection option as well as other available options as applicable.
Way 7. Use OBS Alternative Tool
If the problem is not solved even after trying out all the above-mentioned ways to fix OBS dropping frames recording, you need to switch to a better alternative for recording high-quality videos without drop frame issue. We recommend Wondershare Filmora which is a professional video recorder and video editor application. You can record your screen and webcam at any resolution and record audio from different sources as well. Most importantly, it uses the system resources optimally to avoid frame dropping issues. Here are the steps to record screen with Filmora.
For Win 7 or later (64-bit)
For macOS 10.12 or later
Step 1: Download and install Wondershare Filmora. Launch Filmora and click on PC Screen option for screen recording.
Step 2: Choose recording screen dimensions and audio sources. You can enable Record Camera Stream option to capture your video through picture-in-picture mode.
Step 3: Click on Record button to start recording. Use F9 hotkey to stop recording. You can your recording instantly and click on Export button to save on your hard drive.
Conclusion
OBS drop frame is probably the most common issue reported by OBS users. Whenever you try to record high-quality videos such as at 4K resolution or you are streaming at high-quality resolution, OBS losing frames is inevitable unless you have a high-end computer. You should try out all the possible ways to avoid the issue. Otherwise, you can switch to Filmora to record high-quality videos without any frame drop issue.
Part 2. How To Fix OBS Dropping Frame?
Way 1. Update OBS & Run as an Administrator
It is important to know that you are using the latest version of OBS. This helps to prevent encoding overload as well as problems due to stuttering. Make sure that you run OBS as an administrator. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Download and install the latest version of OBS Studio.
Step 2: Go to Start menu and search for OBS Studio.
Step 3: Right-click on the OBS icon and select Run As Administrator option.
Way 2. Reduce The Output Resolution
When you reduce the resolution, the video quality gets lowered. But for smooth streaming and recording, you have no other option. When you reduce resolution, you require less CPU usage and less internet bandwidth. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Open OBS and go to Settings.
Step 2: Select Video tab. You will see Base and Output resolution.
Step 3: You have to reduce Output Resolution from the current or default setting.
Step 4: Click Apply for saving the changes followed by Ok button.
Way 3. Reduce The Video Bitrate
OBS generally does not maintain a specified bitrate. It keeps on changing the bitrate as per the available condition like CPU usage level and bandwidth and speed of internet connection. When there are constant changes in the bitrate, there is a likelihood of stuttering effect. Even though it has come up with Dynamic bitrate which will automatically reduce the bitrate, but it increases the bitrate when there is no congestion. You can reduce the bitrate by going through these steps.
Step 1: Open OBS Studio and click on Settings button.
Step 2: Go to Output tab and look for Video Bitrate option.
Step 3: Lower the video bitrate from the default or current value.
Step 4: Click on Apply and OK button.
Way 4. Change OBS Process Priority
By changing the OBS process priority from Normal to Above Normal, there could be more processing power availability for OBS Studio. It helps in solving the problem of frame drop by driving performance from the system for better encoding and rendering. Here are the steps for changing OBS process priority.
Step 1: Launch OBS and go to Settings.
Step 3: Go to Advanced tab and look for Process Priority.
Step 4: You will have to change it to ‘Above Normal’ from ‘Normal’.
Step 5: Click Apply followed by Ok button.
Way 5. Update Network Driver
Dropped frame rates can happen due to the outdated network adapter driver. For this, it is important to look for the latest version of the driver. With up-to-date drivers, there will be a smooth connection when you are streaming or playing online games. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: From Start menu, search for Device Manager and open it.
Step 2: Find Network Adapters and click on it to expand.
Step 3: Find your LAN card and right-click on it.
Step 4: From the menu, select Update Driver option.
Follow the onscreen instruction to complete the process and restart your computer.
Way 6. Turn Off Your Firewall and Antivirus
There can be instances where firewalls can block the port for RTMP. It can interfere with the internet connection leading to dropping frames. Similarly, antivirus software messes with any third-party software and prevents regular operations. You have to temporarily turn off real-time protection as well as the antivirus software. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Go to Start menu and search for Firewall.
Step 2: Open Firewall & Network Protection.
Step 3: Turn off firewall for domain, private and public network temporarily to fix dropping frame issue.
Step 4: Go to Virus & Threat Protection.
Step 5: Under Virus & Threat Protection section. Click on Manage Settings.
Step 6: Turn on real-time Protection option as well as other available options as applicable.
Way 7. Use OBS Alternative Tool
If the problem is not solved even after trying out all the above-mentioned ways to fix OBS dropping frames recording, you need to switch to a better alternative for recording high-quality videos without drop frame issue. We recommend Wondershare Filmora which is a professional video recorder and video editor application. You can record your screen and webcam at any resolution and record audio from different sources as well. Most importantly, it uses the system resources optimally to avoid frame dropping issues. Here are the steps to record screen with Filmora.
For Win 7 or later (64-bit)
For macOS 10.12 or later
Step 1: Download and install Wondershare Filmora. Launch Filmora and click on PC Screen option for screen recording.
Step 2: Choose recording screen dimensions and audio sources. You can enable Record Camera Stream option to capture your video through picture-in-picture mode.
Step 3: Click on Record button to start recording. Use F9 hotkey to stop recording. You can your recording instantly and click on Export button to save on your hard drive.
Conclusion
OBS drop frame is probably the most common issue reported by OBS users. Whenever you try to record high-quality videos such as at 4K resolution or you are streaming at high-quality resolution, OBS losing frames is inevitable unless you have a high-end computer. You should try out all the possible ways to avoid the issue. Otherwise, you can switch to Filmora to record high-quality videos without any frame drop issue.
Part 2. How To Fix OBS Dropping Frame?
Way 1. Update OBS & Run as an Administrator
It is important to know that you are using the latest version of OBS. This helps to prevent encoding overload as well as problems due to stuttering. Make sure that you run OBS as an administrator. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Download and install the latest version of OBS Studio.
Step 2: Go to Start menu and search for OBS Studio.
Step 3: Right-click on the OBS icon and select Run As Administrator option.
Way 2. Reduce The Output Resolution
When you reduce the resolution, the video quality gets lowered. But for smooth streaming and recording, you have no other option. When you reduce resolution, you require less CPU usage and less internet bandwidth. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Open OBS and go to Settings.
Step 2: Select Video tab. You will see Base and Output resolution.
Step 3: You have to reduce Output Resolution from the current or default setting.
Step 4: Click Apply for saving the changes followed by Ok button.
Way 3. Reduce The Video Bitrate
OBS generally does not maintain a specified bitrate. It keeps on changing the bitrate as per the available condition like CPU usage level and bandwidth and speed of internet connection. When there are constant changes in the bitrate, there is a likelihood of stuttering effect. Even though it has come up with Dynamic bitrate which will automatically reduce the bitrate, but it increases the bitrate when there is no congestion. You can reduce the bitrate by going through these steps.
Step 1: Open OBS Studio and click on Settings button.
Step 2: Go to Output tab and look for Video Bitrate option.
Step 3: Lower the video bitrate from the default or current value.
Step 4: Click on Apply and OK button.
Way 4. Change OBS Process Priority
By changing the OBS process priority from Normal to Above Normal, there could be more processing power availability for OBS Studio. It helps in solving the problem of frame drop by driving performance from the system for better encoding and rendering. Here are the steps for changing OBS process priority.
Step 1: Launch OBS and go to Settings.
Step 3: Go to Advanced tab and look for Process Priority.
Step 4: You will have to change it to ‘Above Normal’ from ‘Normal’.
Step 5: Click Apply followed by Ok button.
Way 5. Update Network Driver
Dropped frame rates can happen due to the outdated network adapter driver. For this, it is important to look for the latest version of the driver. With up-to-date drivers, there will be a smooth connection when you are streaming or playing online games. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: From Start menu, search for Device Manager and open it.
Step 2: Find Network Adapters and click on it to expand.
Step 3: Find your LAN card and right-click on it.
Step 4: From the menu, select Update Driver option.
Follow the onscreen instruction to complete the process and restart your computer.
Way 6. Turn Off Your Firewall and Antivirus
There can be instances where firewalls can block the port for RTMP. It can interfere with the internet connection leading to dropping frames. Similarly, antivirus software messes with any third-party software and prevents regular operations. You have to temporarily turn off real-time protection as well as the antivirus software. Here are the steps to follow.
Step 1: Go to Start menu and search for Firewall.
Step 2: Open Firewall & Network Protection.
Step 3: Turn off firewall for domain, private and public network temporarily to fix dropping frame issue.
Step 4: Go to Virus & Threat Protection.
Step 5: Under Virus & Threat Protection section. Click on Manage Settings.
Step 6: Turn on real-time Protection option as well as other available options as applicable.
Way 7. Use OBS Alternative Tool
If the problem is not solved even after trying out all the above-mentioned ways to fix OBS dropping frames recording, you need to switch to a better alternative for recording high-quality videos without drop frame issue. We recommend Wondershare Filmora which is a professional video recorder and video editor application. You can record your screen and webcam at any resolution and record audio from different sources as well. Most importantly, it uses the system resources optimally to avoid frame dropping issues. Here are the steps to record screen with Filmora.
For Win 7 or later (64-bit)
For macOS 10.12 or later
Step 1: Download and install Wondershare Filmora. Launch Filmora and click on PC Screen option for screen recording.
Step 2: Choose recording screen dimensions and audio sources. You can enable Record Camera Stream option to capture your video through picture-in-picture mode.
Step 3: Click on Record button to start recording. Use F9 hotkey to stop recording. You can your recording instantly and click on Export button to save on your hard drive.
Conclusion
OBS drop frame is probably the most common issue reported by OBS users. Whenever you try to record high-quality videos such as at 4K resolution or you are streaming at high-quality resolution, OBS losing frames is inevitable unless you have a high-end computer. You should try out all the possible ways to avoid the issue. Otherwise, you can switch to Filmora to record high-quality videos without any frame drop issue.
Also read:
- "[Updated] In 2024, Premier 8 Safe Video Communication Programs for SMBs"
- "\"[New] In 2024, Maximizing Memories Techniques for Gameplay Recording\""
- "\"Leading Zero-Cost Online Remote Display Tools for Teams\""
- "[Updated] How to Record MOV Files on Windows 11"
- "\"[Updated] 2024 Approved Making Every Sound Count Mac Audio Mastery in Audacity\""
- "\"[Updated] Capture the Action In-Depth Guide to Game Recording on Win10\""
- "\"[Updated] Compact, Powerful Windows 11 Camcorders - A Must-Try List for 2024\""
- "\"[New] 2024 Approved Ideal Remote Recording Gear\""
- "\"[Updated] In 2024, Unplugged Delight Your Guide to Free Screen-Free Games for Android\""
- "Winning the Game of TV Recording on a Budget PC"
- "Innovative Frameworks for Efficient IPTV Recording"
- "\"[New] 2024 Approved Quick Start to Mastering IO Screen Recording\""
- "\"2024 Approved Integrating Virtual Boards Into Remote Discussions IPhone/iPad/Android and Computers\""
- "\"[Updated] 2024 Approved Unveiling the New Era of Screen Capture with Apeaksoft\""
- "\"2024 Approved Evaluating the Superiority of SplitCam's Recording\""
- "\"[Updated] Freeze the Fun Screenshots & Recording in Win10\""
- "\"[New] Unveiling the Secrets An Overview of Using EZ Grabber Professionally\""
- "The Ultimate 5 Remote Video Capture Gadgets"
- "\"[Updated] 2024 Approved The Verdict on Screen Recording Does OBS Surpass Fraps?\""
- "\"[New] 2023'S Best Mobile Emulators Top Choices for Your Classic PSP Adventures\""
- "[Updated] Comparing the Leading Tunefab Screen Recorders for 2024"
- "\"Essential Racing Games The Ultimate 5-List\""
- "\"[New] An All-Inclusive Guide to Initiate Multiplatform Communication via Skype Groups for 2024\""
- "\"[Updated] In 2024, Beyond Cyberlink Hunt for the Ultimate Screen Recording App\""
- "\"2024 Approved Quick & Easy Way to Record iPhone Screens\""
- "\"[Updated] In 2024, Eco-Friendly Recorder - Ads Absolved!\""
- "\"[New] In 2024, Guide Audio-Free Video Recording Methods\""
- "Visionary Entry Critique and Dissection for 2024"
- "\"[Updated] 2024 Approved Exclusive List of Windows 10 Recording Software\""
- "[Updated] The Pathway to Proficient League of Legends Screen Recordings for 2024"
- "[New] In 2024, Best Choices for Switch's HD Gaming"
- "\"High-Quality Video Webcams - Top 5 Combo's With Sound\""
- "\"[New] Best No-Pressure PC Games Guide for 2024\""
- "Capturing PS4 Gaming Magic in Full Detail Using OBS for 2024"
- "[Updated] A Comprehensive List of Incredible Games"
- "[New] The Ultimate Guide to Flawless Remote Recording Experience"
- "\"Pinnacle Screenshots on Mac A Deep Dive Into Top Apps for 2024\""
- "Innovative Ways to Record and Preserve Streaming Sounds Online for 2024"
- "[New] Essential Steps to Achieve Flawless Nocturnal Photography for 2024"
- Updated The Art of the Ken Burns Effect Tips and Tricks for Stunning Results
- Updated Trim Videos Like a Pro 10 Free Online Editors 2023 Guide
- New In 2024, Game On! 3 Simple Ways to Record Your Gaming Sessions
- 11 Proven Solutions to Fix Google Play Store Not Working Issue on Lava Yuva 3 | Dr.fone
- In 2024, Does iTools virtual location not work On Apple iPhone SE (2020)/iPad? | Dr.fone
- In 2024, Getting the Pokemon Go GPS Signal Not Found 11 Error in Xiaomi Redmi Note 12R | Dr.fone
- Precision Sound Engineering Harnessing the Power of Keyframes for Audio Fade-Ins/Outs in Filmora (Mac) for 2024
- Updated The Most Reliable Sites to Stream Legal Background Music Collections
- What Is AI Voice Text to Speech?
- A Complete Guide To OEM Unlocking on Realme GT Neo 5
- Updated 2024 Approved Brighten Up Best Video Editing Tools for Luminance Control
- Will Pokémon Go Ban the Account if You Use PGSharp On Motorola Moto G23 | Dr.fone
- 5 Ways to Restart Vivo V27e Without Power Button | Dr.fone
- New Revamping Your Soundtrack? Check Out the Best Audio Normalizers for Windows Users for 2024
- What is the best Pokemon for pokemon pvp ranking On Oppo F23 5G? | Dr.fone
- Top 15 Augmented Reality Games Like Pokémon GO To Play On Motorola Razr 40 | Dr.fone
- Vivo V29e Stuck on Screen – Finding Solutions For Stuck on Boot | Dr.fone
- T2 Pro 5G Music Recovery - Recover Deleted Music from T2 Pro 5G
- How to Hide/Fake Snapchat Location on Your Oppo Find X7 | Dr.fone
- In 2024, How to Bypass Android Lock Screen Using Emergency Call On Nokia C22?
- New 2024 Approved Guide on How to Enable the Text to Speech Function on iPhone
- Title: "[Updated] Stop Frames Dropping OBS Troubleshooting Guide for 2024"
- Author: Queen
- Created at : 2024-05-18 10:03:37
- Updated at : 2024-05-19 10:03:37
- Link: https://screen-mirroring-recording.techidaily.com/updated-stop-frames-dropping-obs-troubleshooting-guide-for-2024/
- License: This work is licensed under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0.